Thinking about adding a second unit to your property? Whether you’re looking for extra rental income, a space for family, or a boost to your home’s value, investing in an ADU can seem like a smart move. But is it the right choice for you? Before you commit, it’s important to weigh the costs, benefits, and potential challenges to make sure it’s a sound financial decision.
What is an ADU
An accessory dwelling unit (ADU) goes by many names—backyard cottage, granny flat, in-law suite, she-shed, man cave, tiny home, and the list goes on. Regardless of what you call it, an ADU is a secondary housing unit located on the same lot as a primary residence. It can be attached (like a converted basement or attic) or detached (like a cottage in the backyard). However, to be considered an ADU, it must be a self-contained living space with a kitchen and bathroom. If the space does not contain a kitchen and bathroom, it is considered a guest house, which does not have to meet the same zoning and building code requirements as an ADU.
Guest House vs. ADU
In most Oregon cities and municipalities, guest houses are legally distinct from ADUs. Legally, homeowners may use guest houses only for temporary stays and cannot rent them out as independent living spaces. This is because guest houses often lack either a kitchen, a bathroom, or both—meaning they do not meet the self-sufficiency requirements for long-term occupancy. On the other hand, an ADU provides a fully self-contained dwelling with its own kitchen, bathroom, and living space, making it suitable for rental use or permanent residency—subject, of course, to local zoning and permitting rules.
Is Adding an ADU a Good Investment?
Adding an ADU can be a worthwhile investment, but several factors determine whether it will provide strong financial returns. Here are some things to consider:
1. Rental Income Potential
ADUs can generate passive income through long-term rentals or short-term vacation rentals (where permitted). In high-demand rental markets like Portland, Eugene, and Salem, ADU rents can range from $1,000 to $2,000 per month, depending on size, location, and amenities. If local zoning allows short-term rentals (like Airbnb), you may be able to earn even more—but keep in mind that most Oregon cities have strict rules on short-term rentals in residential areas.
2. Property Value Increase
A well-designed ADU can increase the overall value of your home. Studies suggest that homes with ADUs can sell for 20-35% more than similar homes without one. However, the actual value increase depends on factors like:
- The quality and design of the ADU
- Whether it’s detached, attached, or a garage conversion
- The overall demand for multi-generational or rental-friendly housing in your area
- Local buyer interest—some buyers may prefer a traditional backyard over an ADU, while others see it as a major asset
3. Upfront Costs vs. Return on Investment (ROI)
Building an ADU requires a significant initial investment. In Oregon, construction costs for an ADU typically range from $100,000 to $300,000, depending on the size, materials, and labor costs. Here’s a rough breakdown:
- Garage conversion: $80,000–$150,000
- Detached ADU (new build): $150,000–$300,000+
- Attached ADU (conversion or addition): $100,000–$250,000
To determine whether the investment makes sense for you, compare your expected rental income to your financing costs. For example, if you build an ADU for $150,000 and rent it for $1,500 per month, you’d generate $18,000 per year in rental income. That means it would take about 8–10 years to break even. And, of course, that doesn’t include the added maintenance costs or tax implications.
4. Local Market Considerations
The profitability of an ADU also depends on your local housing market. In cities with high demand for rentals (like Portland, Salem, and Eugene), an ADU is more likely to pay off quickly. However, in areas with lower rental demand or strict regulations on ADU rentals, the return on investment may take longer.
5. Regulatory Considerations
Speaking of local regulations, the added cost of things like permitting fees, utility hookups, and property tax implications, can significantly affect an ADU’s overall profitability. To determine whether or not an ADU is a sound investment in your area, make sure you understand these costs upfront.
6. Flexibility and Future Use
If financial returns aren’t your biggest concern, ADUs do offer a lot of flexibility and may enhance your day-to-day quality of life. For example, they are perfect for:
- Housing for aging parents (a cost-saving alternative to assisted living)
- A guest house for family and friends
- A home office or creative studio
- An entertainment hub for gaming, movies, or watching sports
- A fitness studio or wellness retreat
- Future downsizing—some homeowners move into the ADU later in life and rent out the main house for retirement income
Final Verdict: Is an ADU Worth It?
Whether you use it as a mobile office, an in-law suite, or a calming retreat, an ADU can undoubtedly be put to good use. But at a cost of $80,000 to $300,000+, is it worth it? Ultimately, it comes down to your needs and resources. An ADU can be a great investment if:
✅ You plan to rent it out for a steady income
✅ You’re comfortable with the upfront costs and financing options
✅ You want to increase your home’s resale value
✅ You have a long-term vision for its use (whether as a rental, guest house, or future living space)
However, it might not be the best choice if:
❌ You don’t have the funds or financing options to cover construction costs
❌ You live in an area with low rental demand or restrictive ADU regulations
❌ You don’t want to deal with being a landlord
If you’re considering an ADU, be sure to research local zoning laws, financing options, and rental demand to make an informed decision. Before taking the plunge, consult with a real estate expert or contractor to ensure that your ADU project makes financial sense. Adding an ADU might be a smart financial move, but careful planning and research are essential if you want that ADU to align with your long-term financial goals.
Want more home improvement tips?
- Discover some affordable ways to refresh your home.
- Find out what a HELOC is (and how to use one).
- Learn the basic steps you should take before selling your home.